Finally caught this flick after much waiting.
Here's the breakdown. This is one of the best films if not *the* best film of the year. I've searched pretty hard in this one viewing, and I can find only a couple of minor flaws. More on those in a bit.
I love the cinematography. The rough 16mm look and the handheld camera in every scene. It gives a weight and rawness to the look that carries the strength and potency of the plot through to a transcendant level.
The plot, it's both sad and beautiful. The plotline of the remorseful martyr for some reason never grows old to me, and this story (although it rings painfully close to the real life of my wife) at times is shocking, comfortable, irritating, and whimsical in just the right balance. Truly an original in the field of european remakes and boring stories that normally fall out of hollywood.
The performances were strong across the board. I have no idea what Iñárritu does to inspire or motivate his actors, but he finds depth in the characters like you find seldomly in directors today. I thought of the powerhouse performances that Mike Nichols pulled from Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor in "Who's afraid of Virginia Woolf" while watching this film, not that I think that 21 grams tops it, but that there is nothing else even close to rivaling it in this day and age other than 21 grams. Penns performace in Mystic River (that's a whole other conversation) fell weak and silent compared to his role here. Benicio Del Toro played the role of his lifetime in this character that was complicated in both his rage and his redemption. Naomi Watts had a more difficult time, and this is probably due to one of the only flaws in the script that I could pick on, there wasn't enough time to develop the complexity and anguish of Watts' character. But it can be forgiven, you could see that she gives her all in every scene. The weakest performance in my opinion was Charlotte Gainsbourg as the girlfriend. I think she could have played up the despiration of
her situation in a little more frantic manner and sold the character a little more convinsingly, but that's an aesthetic choice. Perhaps by leaving her character a little more subdued, Iñárritu left room for the three main character to pull off truely stellar performances. It's a shame though given the quality of her european work. Perhaps she'll be given a chance to cut loose in a deeper role soon.
Last, but not least, the editing... I find that the Terrintino timeline is working it's way into more and more feature film directors psyche. Some pull it off rather badly, and I think Terrentino himself has a hard time putting it into words exactly why his disjointed style works. There is style, poise, and balance to Iñárritu use of this technique however. There is a balance from the beginning of the film to the end, and you notice that somewhere in the middle time starts to look more linear. Until the end when the events of the end and beginning are perfectly tied together.
Beautifully executed from beginning to end, I give this film a 10/10 but a zero on the dancing monkey scale (which is always a good thing).